Accounts Receivable Management Featured Article

Debt Collectors Can Legally Leave Voice Messages

May 15, 2012

Collection agencies are almost always the bad guys in the news, but, a recent case from earlier this month, Zortman v. J.C. Christensen & Associates Inc., shows that sometimes collection agencies are entitled to certain behaviors, lest they be bound by a Catch 22.

In this case, analyzed by JDSUPRA, the Plaintiff, Christina Zortman filed litigation against the named defendant, a collection agency. Zortman leant her children her cell phone, and they received a subsequent message intended for their mother from the collection agency.

Zortman’s stance was that the agency violated the Fair Debt Collecting Practices Act (FDCPA) by “communicating” her debt to a third-party. The judge ruled in favor of the collection agency.

“Communication” is defined by the FDCPA as the “conveying of information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person through any medium.” The message left for Zortman never mentioned her name or the purpose of the phone call. Rather the message only revealed the number for her to contact.

Since this information is the same that would be revealed through Called ID or a missed call log, ruling the defendant’s actions a FDCPA violation would prohibit collection agencies from using the phone altogether.

This is where things get hairy. The FCDPA instructs Collection Agencies to state “that the debt collector is attempting to collect a debt and that any information obtained will be used for that purpose.”

It can be difficult, though, to protect the privacy of the debtor in situations where third parties answer the phone. How would this agency know that Zortman’s children would be using her personal cell phone? There can’t be an “inferred” third-party; therefore, agencies are permitted to leave vague messages.

It’s doubtful that the collector/debtor relationship has ever been analyzed to the extent that it has prior to The Recession. Perhaps the debtor empowerment campaigns of various organizations have left debtors feeling overly confident because Zortman and her legal team were very presumptuous with this litigation.

Recent attention to the egregious actions of collection agencies have sometimes resulted in severe amounts of punitive damages. The Fair Trade Commission has worked overtime in amending existing laws and raising awareness of debtor rights. But this case shows that unless some jurisdictions rule in favor of the agencies, third-party collectors might be confined to sitting around and crossing their fingers that people will pay up.




Edited by Braden Becker

Article comments powered by Disqus

Related Accounts Receivable Management Articles

CSG's Video Billing Initiative keeps Pace with Time Warner's Seasoned Customers

Whether it's an offshoot of wanting to genuinely enhance customer service or whether it's another gimmick to stay alive in a world of cut-throat competition, we'll never know, but no matter what it is, cable companies are coming out with new ways to increase customer loyalty and reduce service cost. Time Warner is going next-generation with its customer care and is now wooing customers with CSG's video billing initiative- SmartVideo. [ Read More ]
10/14/2014

Esker Energizes Direct Energie with Digitized Handling of Vendor Invoices

Document management solutions provider Esker helps DIrect Energie automate accounts payable. [ Read More ]
10/13/2014

Alta Vista Technology Enhances Its Portfolio with Intacct Cloud Financial Applications

Alta Vista Technology adds Intacct cloud-based financial system to its capabilities. [ Read More ]
10/13/2014

Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals Rules for Violation of TCPA

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act was passed in 1991 as an amendment to the Communications Act of 1934. The amendments provide certain protections for consumers and restrictions for solicitors, including: the barring of solicitous calling between the hours of 9 p.m. and 8 a.m. and the requirement that solicitors respect the National Do Not Call Registry. It also prohibits using autodialers in certain situations, and a recent ruling from the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that autodial… [ Read More ]
10/13/2014
FREE Accounts Receivable Management enewslettter.

Events

Weekly Live Demo
Contact Center Solutions

Register Today!


Weekly Live Demo
CaaS Small Center

Register Today!